Negotiations – Fast but not so Furious

27.10.2020

Fast but not so Furious – Successful communication styles in M&A transactions

Negotiation is a fundamental part of everyday life. From haggling over the price of a new car to convincing your partner what to have for dinner, most people engage in hundreds of negotiations every single day.

Of course, in M&A negotiation is a crucial part of the process. Numerous negotiations are required at all stages, including engagement methodology, timetables, pricing, and transaction terms and conditions. Negotiations commence on the first contact between M&A counterparties and extend to, and in certain cases even beyond, financial close of the transaction.

Because all negotiations involve aspects of both collaboration and competition (Pruitt 1983[1]), the choice of communication style becomes critical for conveying your intentions to your counterpart and can have an enormous impact on the success (or failure) of any transaction.

In 2017 Harvard Business School[2] undertook structured research into the effectiveness of communications styles in distributive negotiations. This study found that negotiators with a tough and firm communication style achieved better economic outcomes than negotiators with a warm and friendly communication style.  This was driven by the fact that offers delivered in tough and firm language elicited more favorable counteroffers within the designated timeframes.

Importantly, the counterparties of tough and firm negotiators did not report different levels of satisfaction or enjoyment of their interactions than those engaged in warm and friendly discussions. The report also found that this finding was in fact in direct opposition to participants preconceived belief that warmly worded negotiation offers will be better liked and will achieve better economic outcomes.

It is important to emphasise that tough and firm language in this context does not become aggressive or emotive, rather is focused on direct and assertive language with an expectation of timely outcomes within defined deal parameters.

So what does this mean for InterFinancial? For us, being “firm and tough” means:

  • Helping clients prepare for a transaction, and delivering a “reality check” where there’s a gap in expectations. We will NEVER take a business to market if we don’t think there’s a high probability of success;
  • Running a structured transaction process, rather than “putting it out there to see if we get any nibbles”;
  • Making sure that all communication sets boundaries for our discussions, clearly articulates non-negotiables and is direct with counterparties on key issues and risks so that we can build an effective outcome together;
  • Finding and resolving potential deal-breakers early rather than delaying any awkward discussion;
  • Setting deadlines and driving the transaction process forward; and
  • Being honest and open in all our communication – no game or ultimatums.

Of course, we also need to remember that we are dealing with real people, and life’s too short to work with people you don’t like. There is definitely a place for “warm and friendly”. But a structured, disciplined approach with clear communication will go a long way to making the process slightly less stressful and delivering the best outcome for all parties.


[1] Pruitt DG (1983) Strategic choice in negotiation. Amer. Behavioral Scientist 27(2):167–194.

[2] Martha Jeong, Julia Minson, Michael Yeomans, Francesca Gino (2019) Communicating with Warmth in Distributive Negotiations Is Surprisingly Counterproductive. Management Science 65(12):5813-5837. https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2018.3199

19.4.2021

Sector Dashboards April 2021

Our monthly dashboards cover seven key sectors of focus, with each sector built up by several subsectors that cover similar companies based on; products, end markets, services, assets classes or other characteristics. The publications include all companies listed on the Australian Stock Exchange that are actively traded and covered by research analysts, and hence have […]

Read more
19.4.2021

The M&E in M&A

There has been a strong start to 2021 in Australian M&A with $7.5 billion in reported transactions. With increasing activity in the market, InterFinancial is regularly asked by clients what their business is worth. In the world of M&A, a commonly used valuation method is the ‘Capitalisation of Earnings’ or ‘Earnings multiple’ method. While industry […]

Read more
31.3.2021

Sector Dashboards March 2021

Our monthly dashboards cover seven key sectors of focus, with each sector built up by several subsectors that cover similar companies based on; products, end markets, services, assets classes or other characteristics. The publications include all companies listed on the Australian Stock Exchange that are actively traded and covered by research analysts, and hence have […]

Read more
31.3.2021

Strategic Planning Tips For Successful Acquisitions

Australian M&A activity is on the rise, with $8 billion in transactions closed so far this calendar year, up 30% year-on-year.1 Both financial and strategic investors are taking advantage of cheap debt and strong economic tailwinds to identify value adding acquisitions. Of course, identifying acquisitions and making them work are two very different things. A […]

Read more
26.2.2021

Sector Dashboards February 2021

Our monthly dashboards cover seven key sectors of focus, with each sector built up by several subsectors that cover similar companies based on; products, end markets, services, assets classes or other characteristics. The publications include all companies listed on the Australian Stock Exchange that are actively traded and covered by research analysts, and hence have […]

Read more
16.2.2021

IFL Ventures advises Frontline Accounting on its 80% sale to Sierra Madre

InterFinancial, through its IP focused division IFL Ventures, has advised business process outsourcing (BPO) company, Frontline Accounting on its 80% sale to the Philippines-based PE firm Sierra Madre. Frontline Accounting is a provider of offshore staffing solutions from the Philippines to accounting firms based in Australia, UK and USA. It experienced strong growth since its […]

Read more
28.1.2021

2020 Year in Review – a Pandemic, a Trade-War, and All-Time Highs

Financial Markets Overview 2020 proved to be a year of challenges (to say the least!!!). COVID, drought & bushfires, trade wars and Australia’s first economic recession in 29 years – 2020 had it all. The March Quarter was the most volatile trading period in history, with financial markets reaching all-time highs in February 2020 before […]

Read more
21.1.2021

Sector Dashboards January 2021

Our monthly dashboards cover seven key sectors of focus, with each sector built up by several subsectors that cover similar companies based on; products, end markets, services, assets classes or other characteristics. The publications include all companies listed on the Australian Stock Exchange that are actively traded and covered by research analysts, and hence have […]

Read more
17.12.2020

Idea 11 & PieLAB aiming for the cloud

IFL Ventures acted as corporate advisor to Brisbane based IT consulting company Idea 11 on partnering with Australian based diversified investment group PieLAB Council Capital. PieLAB has made a significant investment in the full-stack AWS IT company but it is not the capital backing that drove Idea 11’s decision.  “In PieLAB we found not only […]

Read more
17.12.2020

Sector Dashboards December 2020

Our monthly dashboards cover seven key sectors of focus, with each sector built up by several subsectors that cover similar companies based on; products, end markets, services, assets classes or other characteristics. The publications include all companies listed on the Australian Stock Exchange that are actively traded and covered by research analysts, and hence have […]

Read more