Traps in post-merger integration

20.6.2019

So, you have found a growth partner, survived the due diligence process, closed the transaction and held the celebration dinner. Congratulations!! You are now at day 1 of the rest of your business’ future. All the promises made are now long in the rear-view mirror and the day to day running of the merged business becomes the new reality. How do you make sure that all the value both parties saw in the merger are realised?

Once a transaction is completed the number of people involved grows exponentially. The curtain is peeled back. The Profit & Loss owner and their operations team begin to interact with the acquired business. As hard as everyone involved in the transaction works through the process, the first few days, weeks and months are critical to embedding the merger and capitalising on the best of both organisations. You start to hear questions like; What is going to happen to my job? Who do I report to? What do we tell our customers? Whose system do we use? What is going to happen with the brand? Who gets credit for the sale? Where does the profit margin go?

While deal teams always feel like they have a plan, the business outcomes 12 months post transaction often don’t meet the initial expectations of either party. Research suggests that approximately 79% of organisations believe they achieve transaction success (good pricing). However, only 65% believe they achieve strategic success (the right deal), 49% financial success (cost synergies/revenue synergies/capital synergies), and just 35% believe they achieve operational success (integration) (1). Furthermore, when questioning executives on the key factor of success in M&A, the top answer was a well-executed integration plan (2).

So why is this? While every case is unique, some of the more common traps include:

  • The absence of a very clear vision of the future state;
  • Over-simplification of the complexity of the integration process;
  • Lack of tactical detail the leadership team, sales and operations teams need to resolve their day to day conflicts efficiently and effectively;
  • The absence of a step by step plan for how to get there;
  • Failure to resource said plan;
  • Or most commonly, a combination of all the above.

Best practice starts with a clear vision for the combined entity, including a clear understanding of the values and behaviours the combined organisation must exhibit to succeed. This needs to be followed up with a clear and detailed plan for integration which has been developed by the functional and operational leaders of the business. The plan needs to be robust enough to survive the various tests the integration will throw at it.

Operational goals are often the most difficult to achieve because they require a sustained commitment to integration delivery. However, if done right, these can provide the greatest benefit due to their recurring nature and are often the key driver of sustained value creation from M&A activity.

InterFinancial’s growth advisory team is well versed in helping clients develop and execute effective post-merger integration plans. Drawing on our broad M&A experience and regular interaction with investors, our goal is to not just close deals, but to help you make sure the transaction is successful over the longer term.

(1) Calipha, R, Tarba, S., and Brock, D. Mergers and Acquisitions: A review of phases, motives, and success factors. Advances in Mergers and Acquisitions, Volume 9, 1-24. 2010

(2) KPMG. US executives on M&A 2016

Authors: Michael Kakanis & Brad Shaw

31.3.2025

Sector dashboards March 2025

Our monthly sector dashboards are out! Our dashboards look at the valuation multiples across seven key sectors, each made up of a number of subsectors. The data takes into account the sale prices of similar companies based on; products, end markets, services, assets classes or other characteristics. The publications include all companies listed on the […]

Read more
Solar panels and wind turbines in the middle of a field
31.3.2025

Towards net zero: Four key considerations for organisations on a decarbonisation journey

Strong geo-political, social and economic forces are influencing the pace of global investment in decarbonisation. Driven by economic factors, the Trump administration’s stance to curb action on climate change stands at one end of the decarbonisation investment approach, whereas other countries in Europe and Asia Pacific (including Australia) recognise they are behind in their quest […]

Read more
31.3.2025

Building an M&A dream team – What you need to know

As the old saying goes, there’s no I in team. But there is an M&A!  One of the most crucial factors determining the success (or otherwise) of a business sale or acquisition is selecting the right team. Transactions are hard work and typically involve a set of skills that are unfamiliar to a business owner. […]

Read more
31.3.2025

Employee Q&A: Brad Shaw

From mining sites to boardrooms, Brad’s career has spanned various industries, continents and more air miles than he can count. As InterFinancial’s CEO, he’s led multiple businesses through growth, change, and the curveballs – always with a strategic eye on what’s next.   With his 25+ years of experience, Brad has seen what works (and what […]

Read more
Businessman putting money on stack of coins with tree on top of it
26.2.2025

Is your business investment ready? How to raise enterprise value from an investor’s lens.

Working ON your business is just as important as working IN your business.   For many business owners, their business is their primary asset. But like with any asset, it requires regular maintenance to ensure it remains competitive, profitable, and most importantly, investment ready.   It’s important to consider the following key questions towards becoming investor ready:  […]

Read more
26.2.2025

Sector dashboards February 2025

Our monthly sector dashboards are out! Our dashboards look at the valuation multiples across seven key sectors, each made up of a number of subsectors. The data takes into account the sale prices of similar companies based on; products, end markets, services, assets classes or other characteristics. The publications include all companies listed on the […]

Read more
29.1.2025

Sector dashboards January 2025

Our monthly sector dashboards are out! Our dashboards look at the valuation multiples across seven key sectors, each made up of a number of subsectors. The data takes into account the sale prices of similar companies based on; products, end markets, services, assets classes or other characteristics. The publications include all companies listed on the […]

Read more
29.1.2025

Done deal? Why many Mergers and Acquisitions miss the mark

Mergers and Acquisitions (M&A) are often seen as a golden ticket for businesses aiming to expand, achieve economies of scale, or diversify. Yet business history is littered with stories of failed acquisitions that have eroded value rather than enhanced it. Look no further than Catch.com, which is still in the news cycle. Why? Below are […]

Read more
29.1.2025

Employee Q&A: Lucy Clarke

We’re excited to dive into a round of Q&A with Lucy Clarke, a talented and passionate M&A Associate at InterFinancial. In this post, Lucy shares her insights on the daily grind, the rewarding aspects of her role, and the challenges she overcomes. Join us as we explore what it’s like to be an M&A professional […]

Read more